|
Leading
News
War on monga : CA
Cultivate diversified food
UNB, Gangachhara, Rangpur
Chief Adviser Dr Fakhruddin Ahmed on Sunday announced an
action plan for removing ‘Monga’ from the country’s
northern region forever through well-coordinated
programmes of the government, NGOs and private sector, as
the lean-season dearth of food and work put people in
misery.
"The government is keeping strict and intense attention
about Monga. It is a temporary problem temporary
unemployment problem," he told an exchange-of- opinion
meeting in the morning on the second day of his stay in
this backwater northern district.
The head of caretaker government was exchanging views with
people of different professions and officials of
Gangachhara upazila at the meet organized by the local
administration at the upazila parishad ground.
Commander of Muktijoddha Sangsad of the upazila M Azizul
Islam, president of the Gangachhara imam association AKM
Nurunnabi Ansari, Nure Alam Sarker of BRAC, president of
Gangachhara press club Sazu Ahmed Lal, principal of
Gangachhara Degree College Anisur Rahman, union parishad
chairman Anwarul Islam, president of Rangpur Chamber of
Commerce and Industry Mostafa Azad Chowdhury and UNO of
Gangachhara Mukesh Chandra Biswas, among others, spoke at
the meeting presided over by Rangpur deputy commissioner
Khandokar M Atiar Rahman.
Gangachhara is a Monga-prone area of the greater Rangpur
district. The seasonal crisis of unemployment and food
usually occurs during October-November period in the
agrarian northern region, lacking in industries and other
income-generating modern vocations.
Focusing on ways of eradicating Monga, he said a committee
headed by the Commerce Adviser was formed at Saturday’s
Advisory Council meeting in Rangpur to coordinate all
ongoing projects regarding Monga-and poverty-alleviation
programes of the government and NGOs and other
organizations aiming to formulate a multidimensional plan
of action to permanently end this endemic penury.
The Chief Adviser suggested cultivation of diversified
food and other crops, undertaking income-generation
projects and massive export of manpower to foreign
countries from the northern region through imparting
training to them at various training centres and
institutes in the country. He said he has instructed the
authorities concerned for full-fledged run of Technical
Training Centres and Institutes existing in many
districts, which virtually remained inoperative, for their
best utilization in developing skilled manpower in
demanding fields.
As part of the new thinking about resolving the nagging
problem, the head of interim government suggested that the
people of the northern region could migrate for employment
to other parts of the country.
Mentioning some of the synergized steps taken for
resolving the problem last year, he expressed happiness
over the outcome and told his audience that early
preparation of steps and programmes in the current year
would be much wider and coordinated in fighting Monga.
Patients helpless
in DMCH
Firoz Mamun
As the country’s pioneering government hospital, Dhaka
Medical College Hospital, has earned fame but patients who
along with their relatives visit it everyday, face serious
difficulties due to harassment by the cheats, touts and a
section of employees.
As soon as a patient specially the poor and the middle
class reach the DMCH gate, they fall prey to the cheats.
In the name of better treatment these organised groups
start convincing the patients’ relatives in a bid to
transfer them to the private clinics. If these thugs fail
to convince relatives of the patients, they issue threats.
The helpless people with their injured or sick patients
suffering from different complicated diseases, have
clearly nothing to do but flop down on the premises of the
DMCH and lament.
A patient’s relative told The Bangladesh Today, "There is
no more good treatment in the DMCH. When I have just
reached the hospital gate with my patient and yet to enter
into hospital building, these people are issuing threat
and alluring saying they provide better treatment to my
patient. They also dragged me into a room and asked me to
go with them to a private clinic."
The officials of the DMCH said in the face of massive raid
by the joint forces these organised cheats, touts and
criminals went into hiding. But within a short time they
returned to the DMCH and became active.
Meanwhile, mother of a school girl patient released
yesterday from the DMCH told this correspondent, "Without
giving bribe allocation seat and guarantee of proper
treatment are not possible. A fourth class employee
demanded of me Tk 200 extra for a seat. As I failed to
meet his demand, he threw my daughter on the floor and did
not allocate the seat. However, the seat was lying vacant
for the whole night. I had to pass the night along with my
daughter on the floor."
The patients and relatives also alleged that the hospital
staffs who are employed to take care of the patients,
extort extra money from the patients in the name of
providing medicine and other medical materials. On the
other hand, a stink always hovers in and around the DMCH
due to indiscriminate dumping of medical wastes which
cause disease and illness to humans through direct contact
or indirect contamination to soil, ground water, surface
water and air.
Within the hospital wards, wastes from patients are
collected in small bowls and plastic bins. The wastes are
then thrown indiscriminately in and around the DMCH under
the very nose of the authority.
There are 48 wards and 1700 beds with the capacity to
treat 1700 patients in the DMCH. But 2000 patients
exceeding capacity of the hospital are being treated
everyday. There are 251 government doctors except some
professors of the Dhaka Medical College and interns in the
hospital as against 2000 patients. Specially, the wards
for causality and poison treatment are overcrowded.
Service sector corruption
Staff Correspondent
The
country’s state-owned organisations in the service sector
suffered a loss of Taka 4228.20 crore during the fiscal
year 2006-07 because of widespread corruption and
irregularities. During the last fiscal year, the amount of
financial loss increased by Taka 279.65 crore compared to
the previous fiscal 2005-06. In the fiscal year 2005-06,
the organisations incurred a loss of Taka 3848.55 crore.
Sources said, corrupt practices are going on in full swing
in the offices of public service sector as the corrupt
officials and employees are yet to be picked up and
brought to justice as part of on-going anti-corruption
drive throughout the country. A section of unscrupulous
officials, employees and trade union leaders in government
offices are mainly responsible for causing a huge sum of
financial loss to the country since independence.
In the public service sector, the most corruption-plagued
offices are Rajdhani Unnayan Katripakkha (Rajuk), Dhaka
City Corporation (DCC), Dhaka Wasa, Power Development
Board, DESA, Bangladesh Telephone and Telegraph Board,
Titas Gas Transmission and Distribution Company Limited,
it is alleged.
Sources said, the authorities are preparing the list of
the corrupts in the government offices in order to take
stern action against them to rid the country of
corruption.
According to DESA sources, the amount of unrealised
revenue from the consumers of of the organisation was
around Taka 809.89 crore in June in 2006. On the other
hand, the office was owing a total of Taka 3086.47 crore
to other public and private organizations during the same
period.
Frustration chases job
seekers
Sahidul Islam Rana
Income
generation across the country is now at a stand still
especially in the private sector as the investment has not
increased satisfactorily in the last one year.
On the other hand, the prices of the essentials have
already gone beyond capacity of common people. In the
changed circumstances, scopes of employment or
opportunities for job did not increase; rather reduced by
a big margin intensifying the uncertainty of jobseekers,
specially for the outgoing university students.
This was due to lack of proper work-monitoring system in
the concerned institutions and want of confidence among
the investors and less Annual Development Programme (ADP)’s
implementation.
Talking to The Bangladesh Today, leaders of chambers of
commerce industries expressed their almost same opinion
saying, "As part of overcoming the prevailing situation,
restoration of democracy is a must."
The outgoing president of Federation of Bangladesh
Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FBCCI), Mir Nasir Uddin
said, "The investment must increase to rejuvinate the job
market with a view to facing the unemployment problems
across the country." He also proposed to reduce the tax in
the investment sector. Nasir Uddin underscored the need
for strengthening the monitoring the overall activities of
related agencies adding the concerned ministries of the
government can play a very significant role in this
regard.
President of Dhaka Chamber of Commerce Industries (DCCI)
emphasised on growing confidence among the investors, who
were apparently demoralized at the fag end of the
erstwhile BNP-Jamaat coalition government and immediately
after the promulgation of the state of emergency since
very beginning of the last year.
Politics
AL
Lifting of emergency demanded
Staff Correspondent
Awami League (AL) leaders at a discussion meeting on
Sunday demanded of the caretaker government to lift the
state of emergency and to announce the date of general
election as early as possible.
"AL is always ready to hold dialogue without preconditions
with the caretaker government to resolve all
socio-political and economic problems," they said urging
the authorities to finalise the agenda for the ensuing
dialogue within the shortest possible time. They urged the
government to bring the real killers and perpetrators of
all political killings, including Kibria murder and 21
August grenade attack, to book after fair investigations.
They also demanded immediate release of the detained AL
leaders including party chief Shiekh Hasina.
Senior party leaders were addressing a discussion meeting
marking the 3rd death anniversary of the former AL finance
minister Shah AMS Kibria at AL central office at
Bangabandhu Avenue yesterday morning.
Bangladesh AL organized the discussion with its presidium
member Begum Sajeda Chowdhury in the chair.
Sajeda Chowdhury urged the caretaker government to allow
indoor politics across the country so that the party
leaders and activists can exchange views with the people.
She demanded early general election to restore democracy
in the country.
AL presidium member Amir Hossain Amu said, "There is no
split in AL. It’s always united and working as per the
decision of the party presidium meeting."
Without mentioning anybody’s name, Amu said, "If any
leader says anything contradicts the party presidium
decision, he/she will be treated as a conspirator with the
aim to create confusion among the rank and file of AL."
AL to
continue anti-graft drive if elected: Zillur
Dhaka, bdnews24
Acting Awami League president Zillur Rahman said on Sunday
his party would press on with anti-graft drive and reform
programmes of the interim administration if it was elected
to office in the next elections.
Zillur made the comment to reporters after meeting
detained party chief Sheikh Hasina on the Jatiya Sangsad
premises, after a special court judge allowed the former
prime minister to meet with him.
The judge allowed Zillur, lawyers and relatives to speak
to Hasina for an hour, after the court deferred to Feb 7
indictment proceedings in a corruption case filed by the
ACC.
Hasina has been suffering from various complications
including high blood pressure, Zillur said, adding that
she needed "proper treatment".
He demanded the government free the AL president first and
then announce the election schedules.
He promised to curb the prices of daily commodities by at
least half if his party was voted to power.
BNP
Delwar doubts Khaleda's call for unity
Staff Correspondent
BNP secretary general Khondoker Delwar Hossain on Sunday
expressed doubt whether Begum Khaleda Zia has really
called for reuniting the two factions of BNP.
Meanwhile, lawyer Mahbub Uddin Khokon, who brought the
message of unity from Khaleda Zia on Friday, reiterated
that Begum Zia had called for unity in the party and there
is no reason for anybody to question the authenticity of
Khaleda’s call for unity.
In a crowded press briefing on Sunday at his Nam flat,
Delwar said, "a growing doubt is simmering among the party
workers whether Begum Zia has called for so-called unity
and party leaders and workers are questioning as to why
the message from Khaleda was disclosed to the media before
informing the party secretary general."
"Moreover, it was reported that Mahbubuddin Khokon talked
to M Saifur Rahman for one and a half hours before meeting
Khaleda Zia in jail," Delwar said and hastaend to pose a
question, "Why Begum Zia did not give this message on the
day when she came out of sub-jail on parole. Besides, many
women ex-MPs and workers met her, but she did not talk for
unity. What has happened in just 10 to 12 days that she
called for reuniting the party."
He, however, said, "I am personally in favour of unity. I
am appointed by Begum Khaleda Zia. I will follow whatever
the party chairperson wants."
In reply to a question, he said, "the unity in BNP is not
being forged due to quick shifting of reformists’ stand.
We came to know through the media that Saifur and Hafiz
are ready to relinquish their posts, but now they are
giving conditions. If they abide by the leadership of
Khaleda Zia, then what’s wrong to follow her
instructions?"
The BNP secretary general urged the government to take
necessary steps for better treatment of Tarique Rahman and
Arafat Rahman. He also demanded of the government to set
free Khaleda Zia aiming at creating a congenial atmosphere
for holding the stalled ninth parliamentary election.
Following Delwar’s denial, Mahbub Uddin Khokon called an
impromptu press briefing at his Dhanmondi chamber where he
claimed that "whatever he said before the media on Friday
was true. "If anyone has any doubt about it, they can
check with Begum Zia through lawyers," he added.
Asked whether he contacted M Saifur Rahman regarding
unity, he said, "I contacted him over phone."
Back Page
Gas crisis hits
capital
Repair work continues, food price hikes up
Staff Correspondent
City dwellers mainly living in the south-eastern parts of
the capital have started facing severe gas crisis due to
suspension of its supply for at least 48 hours from Sunday
midnight due to a major repair on the main
gas-transmission line at Daudkandi in Comilla.
Besides, the city dwellers are also experiencing a severe
load shedding from Sunday night as power generation of
some gas-based power plants including Meghnaghat, Haripur
NEPC and Haripur have already been suspended due to
disruption in gas supply.
But taking the opportunity, a section of unscrupulous
businessmen are selling different items of dry foods and
stoves at high rates. Besides, the price of Kerosine has
also gone up as yesterday (Sunday) it was selling between
Tk. 80 and Tk.90 per litre. Even the price of candles has
gone up yesterday and in some places there were shortage
of candles in the markets.In some areas, there is scarcity
of Kerosine and the food price of at many restaurants also
has increased to a large extent.
On Sunday, hundreds of panic-gripped city dwellers and
other people thronged to the different dry food sales
centres and hardware shops to buy stoves. But they had to
pay extra money for getting these items as a result of
artificial crisis of the wares.
Many CNG-run vehicles were seen waiting in long queues for
taking gas. But due to low pressure of gas, some CNG
stations were compelled to shut down their establishments.
The most affected areas include Postagola, Jurain,
Jatrabari, Dhalpur, Bibirbagicha, Gopibagh, Kamalapur,
Khilgaon, Basabo, Shahjahanpur, Badda, Rampura, Ulan,
Tejgaon Industrial area, Mohakhali, Gulshan, Nayatola,
Madhubagh, Shantinagar, Siddheswari, Motijheel, Wari,
Gendaria, Nawabpur, Sadarghat, Sutrapur, Banglabazar,
Bakshibazar, Islampur, Hazaribagh and Azimpur.
Many people were seen cooking extra foods to preserve it
in the refrigerators and even some people also stored up
water in different pots, apprehending acute water supply
in the city in case of any severe load shedding.
Talking to this correspondent, Sultana Razia, a housewife
said, " we have cooked enough foods on Sunday night for
the next two days and we have also stored up enough water
if water supply is disrupted because of power failure
later on."
Talking to The Bangladesh Today, an official Bakhrabad Gas
Transmission Company Limited (GTCL) said, " the repair
work is going on in full swing and the authorities would
be able to resume the gas supply soon."
Titas Gas Transmission and Distribution Company and
Bakhrabad Gas Company are jointly conducting the repair
work on the gas transmission line.
Contractors fear of arrest
Slow pace in implementation of ADP
Dhaka, bdnews24
The fear of arrest among the country's contractors is
contributing to the slow implementation of the current
fiscal's Annual Development Programme, according to a
government report.
The review of the progress in ADP implementation to
December 2007 was presented at the meeting of the
Executive Committee of the National Economic Council (ECNEC)
Wednesday, chaired by chief adviser Fakhruddin Ahmed.
The report prepared by the Implementation, Monitoring and
Evaluation Division (IMED) identified a total of 30 causes
for slow implementation of ADP in ten major ministries.
Increase in the price of construction materials, 2007's
floods and Cyclone Sidr, and delay in preparation of
schedules for tender, evaluation, approval and work order
have been cited as the causes of slow pace in
implementation of the ADP.
The report said of the education ministry: "The work of
infrastructure development is being hampered as the
contractors at the field level have gone underground due
to the overall situation in the country."
The report also said overall ADP implementation was low as
projects regarding roads and embankments were hindered in
the affected areas due to two floods in September-October
and the devastating cyclone Sidr on Nov 15 of 2007.
According to the report's figures, there are 931 projects
under the current fiscal's ADP, with a total allocation of
Tk 26,500 crore.
During the first six months (July-December) of the current
fiscal only 21 per cent of the government's ADP was
implemented, the report said.
This rate is the lowest of the past four years. During the
July-December of the previous fiscal (2006-07) the rate of
ADP implementation was 25 per cent. In 2005-06 and 2004-05
the rates were 27 and 29 per cent respectively. The post
and telecommunication ministry's performance is worst
among the ten major ministries and divisions regarding
implementation of the ADP. The ministry has implemented
only seven per cent of the total allocation during
July-December. In the last fiscal the rate of ADP
implementation in the post and telecommunication ministry
was 11 per cent.
Other reasons for overall slow implementation are:
complexities in selection of projects, acquiring land,
delay in release of money pending different
conditions-including for aid-dependent projects-frequent
transfer of senior ministry officials and lack of
monitoring by the ministry/division/organisation during
implementation of a project.
Legal action against defiant BD workers
UNB, Dhaka
The Expatriate Welfare and Overseas Employment Ministry on
Sunday said adverse impact may be cast on Bangladesh's
labour market in Malaysia due to unpleasant behavior by
few Bangladeshi workers there.
"Working freestyle at other place after taking back
passport from employers is not consistent with labour laws
of Malaysia. Illegal demands raised by these few workers
are not acceptable considering interest of all Bangladeshi
workers in Malaysia as well as overall national interest,"
an official release said. The release said a significant
amount of remittance was sent to Bangladesh in 2007 from
Malaysia, a biggest labour market for the country. So far
2,36,601 Bangladeshi workers went to Malaysia last year.
IFC shows interest in Bangladesh
UNB, Dhaka
International Finance Corporation (IFC), the private
sector arm of the World Bank Group, are interested to
finance Bangladesh's infrastructure and agriculture sector
projects.
IFC executive vice-president Lars Thunell, who is leading
an 8-member delegation, expressed the interest at a
meeting with Bangladesh Bank Governor Dr Salehuddin Ahmed
at the Bangladesh Bank on Sunday. Senior Bangladesh Bank
executives were present.
IFC provides loans, equity, structured finance and risk
management products, and advisory services to build the
private sector in developing countries.
It showed interest in infrastructure sector like oil and
gas, power and communications sectors as a priority, and
the agriculture sector, meeting sources said.
They stressed the need for quick disposal of the potential
investment proposals by the relevant government agencies,
including Board of Investment (BOI). Dr Salehuddin told
reporters after the meeting that the Bangladesh Bank would
discuss with government agencies so that they dispose the
investment proposals as soon as possible to get the IFC
loans quickly.
"We've also requested them to keep the interest rate on
loans as low as possible," he said.
The IFC program in Bangladesh has increased substantially
since the IFC office was opened in Dakha in 1995. There
are 11 projects in the IFC's current portfolio with US$149
million in loans, $12.3 million in equity and $28.5
million in outstanding B-loans.
IFC investments in Bangladesh have spanned a range of
sectors including power, telecommunication, cement, gas,
and the financial markets sector (leasing, development
financial institutions, and housing finance).
In FY02, IFC and other donors established a regional small
business development facility The SouthAsia Enterprise
Development Facility (SEDF) - based in Dhaka, to promote
small business by providing technical assistance in
Bangladesh, Nepal, Bhutan, Sri Lanka and North East India.
Crime Watch
Kabirhat thana inaugurated
A Correspondent, Noakhali
A newly constructed police station at Kabirhat under
Companiganj in the district started operating on Saturday.
Deputy Inspector General (DIG) AKM Shadul Haque formally
inaugurated the opening as chief guest, while Deputy
Commissioner (DC), Habibul Kabir Chowdhury was in the
chair. Police Super of Noakhali, M. Musfiqur Rahman and
Noakhali Army unit commander Lt. Col. Ajij Hakim Arif were
present as special guests. Among others, M. Allha Box Titu,
chairman of Kabirhat pourasabha, government high officials
attended the programme.
SP Musfiqur Rahman said, the station is equipped with five
sub inspectors, twenty police personnel. Including this
thana a total of nine are in the district.
It can be added that Kabirhat consists of seven unions
with one pourasabha while one lakh eighty five thousand
nine hundred forty eight people are living in the area.
Father kills daughter
UNB, Sylhet
A cruel father allegedly hacked his six-year-old daughter
to death at Hamdarchat village in Biswanath upazila here
Saturday.
The dead was identified as Tahmina Begum (6), daughter of
Sohaor Ali.
Local people said Sohaor Stabbed Tahmina indiscriminately
with a sharp dao, leaving her dead on the spot. On
information police rushed to the spot and sent the body to
hospital morgue for autopsy. They also arrested the cruel
father. But the reason behind the murder could not be
known immediately.
Tahminas's uncle Abdul Hamid filed a murder case with the
local police station.
Men held with drugs
UNB, Naogaon
Members of elite force RAB arrested three people including
an upazila election officer while selling one kilogram of
cocaine at Banshbari in Porsha upazila Friday night.
Acting on a tip off, the RAB troops conducted a drive in
the area and caught red handed the Porsha Upazila Election
Officer SM Nasir Uddin, 44, and drug peddlers Kutub Uddin
and M Mahbub of the upazila when they were selling the
drug.
In another drive the RAB personnel also arrested another
drug peddler Enamul Haq along with two-kg hemp at Kalupara
village in Sadar upazila on the same night.
Separate cases were filed with the police.
UP member arrested
BSS, Nilphamari
Joint forces arrested a union parishad member for
distribution of VGF card illegally at
sadar upazila of the district on Thursday.
The arrested person was identified as Belal Hossain, union
parishad (UP) member of Itakhola union under sadar upazila.
He collecting money illegal inn the name of VGF card from
the poor people.
Eyes of two snatchers gouged out
UNB, Mymensingh
Angry mob gouged out eyes of two snatchers at Amirabari in
Trishal upazila Thursday night.
Police said four miscreants picked up two people in their
taxicab and snatched their mobile phone sets and other
belongings.
When they tried to flee away leaving them at Kanhor in the
upazila local people caught two of the snatchers - Jasim
and Sumon. They gave them a good beating and gouged out
their eyes.
The two other snatchers managed to flee leaving their
taxicab behind, police said.
The injured snatchers were admitted to Mymensingh Medical
College Hospital in critical condition.
Trader held
UNB, Bagerhat
A rice trader was arrested while selling Vulnerable Group
Feeding (VGF) rice at Kuliabazar in Mollahat upazila on
Friday.
Acting on secret information police raided the bazar at
noon and arrested the rice trader Mursalin (25), while he
was selling the rice at his shop. They also seized 100kg
VGF rice from the shop.
According to police, Kulia Union Parishad member of Ward
no 8 Abu Sayed misappropriated the VGF rice instead of
distributing among poor people, and sold it to the rice
trader.
Police could not arrest the UP member. A case was filed.
Woman beaten to death
UNB, Sirajganj
A woman was killed by terrorists at Lauta village in
Tarash upazila on Thursday midnight.
The dead was identified as Rashida (28), wife of Jafar
Ali.
Local people said terrorists stormed into the house of
Jafar Ali in his absence and beat his wife Rashida to
death.
On information, police recovered the body and sent it to
Sadar Hospital morgue for autopsy.
Reason behind the killing could not be known immediately.
A case was filed.
3 thieves nabbed
BSS, Chapainawabganj
Three thieves of electric wires were caught red handed at
Rohnpur under Gomostapur upazila in the district on Friday
night.
The arrested were identified as Zahidul Islam (27), of
Hatat Para village, Jasim(15, and Rubel (15), of Nungola
village under the same upazila.
Police said that they arrested them while the thieves were
stealing electric wires of Power Development Board (PDB).
Suicide
BSS, Rajbari
A young man committed suicide by hanging himself here
yesterday.
Police said, the deceased was identified as Arif Mollah
(15) son of Zakir Hossain of village Pershail in Rajbari
sadar upazila of Rajbari district. Family fuel was the
major cause of committing suicide of Arif Mollah, it is
learnt. Police recovered the dead body and sent it for
autopsy to the Rajbari Sadar Hospital.
Clash leaves 2 killed, 10 injured
UNB, Sylhet
Two people were killed and 10 others injured in a bloody
clash between two groups of people at Iqarchhari village
in Jagannathpur upazila of Sunamganj district on Saturday.
The deceased were identified as Ripon Mia (25), son of
Hasmat Ali and Suruj Mia (50), of the village.
Local people said there was a longstanding dispute between
Mostafa Mia and his neighbour Matiur Rahman over a piece
of land.
They said an altercation ensued between the supporters of
Matiur Rahman and Mostafa over the issue at about 10:00
am.
At one stage, both the groups equipped with sharp weapons
attacked each other, leaving the two people dead on the
spot and injuring 10 others from both sides.
On information, police rushed in and brought the situation
under control. The injured were admitted to Sylhet Osmani
Medical College Hospital. A case was filed.
24 injured in clash
UNB, Magura
Twenty-four people were injured in a clash between two
rival groups at Ichhapur village in Sripur upazila Sunday
morning over land dispute.
Local people said there had been a longstanding dispute
between one Moshiur Rahman and his co-villager Hasmat Ali
over a piece of land.
They said the clash ensued in the morning when Hasmat and
his supporters tried to prevent Mashiur from spraying
pesticide on the disputed cropland, leaving 24 people from
the both sides injured.
The belligerent people also ransacked 34 houses and looted
valuables from the houses during the clash.
Later police, RAB members and army personnel rushed to the
spot and brought the situation under control.
Editorial
HC Verdict on
Hasina's Writ
The
Law Adviser, on Thursday last, 31 January 2008, has opined
that the fate of corruption cases under EPR hinges on the High
Court's verdict on Sheikh Hasina's writ challenging the
legality of prosecuting her under the EPR in regard to an
extortion case filed against her. A panel of amici curiae also
contend that crimes committed before the promulgation of
Emergency could not be prosecuted under EPR and if they are so
prosecuted, "it would be a clear violation of the
constitution".
The Law Adviser is of course right but every mindful citizen
is also aware and alive to the consequences of HC's verdict on
the landmark case of Sheikh Hasina. It is of course pointless
and also "subjudice" to speculate on what the HC would say but
one thing is sure, the HC is in a bind; if the judgement goes
for Sheikh Hasina it would "crash and trash" the entire
anti-corruption drive of the Emergency Government and the
expectations of the common people in seeing powerful crooks
being brought to justice, on the other hand if the judgement
goes against Sheikh Hasina that would terribly upset the
political parties who are all now waiting with bated breath to
see many of their leaders get out of jails on some legal
backing or pretext. Well, we all have to wait and see what
happens.
We have been contending in these columns for quite sometime
now that at present there are two systems of law and justice
running side by side in Bangladesh - one is that of the EPR
and other that of the Law of the Land and the Constitution. We
have also contended that at one apex point, that is at the
High Court and the Supreme Court, these systems will
invariably come into conflict at some point of time because
the Laws of the Land and the Constitution are products of
historical experiences ad evolution reflecting social,
political ad economic conditions over long periods of time
whereas EPRs are contingencies to deal with a particular,
defined "time-situation" context. Ultimately the Law of the
Land and the Constitution must prevail, otherwise the entire
system and structure of Law and Justice will collapse. The
polity called variously "the State" or the "Nation-state" can
never allow such a thing or a consequence to come to pass, not
until and unless a revolutionary situation is prevailing such
as in 1971, 1975 and 1991.
Therefore, what the Emergency Government ought to have done,
can still do and indeed must do while there is still time on
its hands, is to prosecute all cases of corruption, which have
spill-over effects on politics and constitutional law, by the
usual laws of the land and prepare those cases and pursue them
in such a way that a judgement in favour of the prosecution is
obtained even at the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court -
the process may take time but that is the only sure and
guaranteed way to ensuring Justice. In other cases prosecution
under EPR must ensure that there are no clashes with the laws
of the land and the Constitution and that the letter and
spirit of justice is followed scrupulously. Only then can EPRs
be effective and uphold the cannons of Law and Justice.
Fertilisers Again!
Somehow the
fertiliser crisis keeps on snowballing particularly when
farmers need it most. Right when the Chief of Army Staff has
been contending that there are no shortages of fertilisers,
there is a crisis looming in the background. Indenters and
importers have stopped the process of imports of fertilisers
because of a 200 percent increase in prices of the stuff in
the international markets since the importers and indenters
bid for government tenders and contracts.
Requirement of fertilisers for the months of February and
March amount to 4 lakh and 3.5 lakh metric tons respectively
out of which about 1.5 lakh metric tons are available from
local fertilizer factories; the shortfall has to be imported.
It is this import of a shortfall of 2 lakh metric tons which
has run into trouble due to sudden rise in prices in
international markets. There is now but one way to solve this
problem quickly before shortages are felt and effect rice
production and that is for the Government to underwrite
imports at these high prices and subsidize sales to farmers
directly.
Like in many other things, in this too the Emergency
Government has shown a terrible lack of foresight and acumen.
The process of importing fertilizers ought to have been taken
in hand right after the floods because it was a foregone
conclusion that as soon as the rehabilitation program starts,
farmers would start cultivation and planting of rice and
demands for fertilizers would rise. But no, our Emergency
Government and its Financial Adviser were then claiming that
agriculture has negligible impact on the economy of
Bangladesh. On 19 November 2007, the Finance Adviser said :
"the agriculture - GDP ratio of the country is not more than
22 percent and in that percentage there are so many things
like livestock and fisheries". It is exactly this sort of
shortsightedness that is pushing us daily to live out our
lives from one crisis to another. Now, of course our
Government will spend our hard-earned foreign currency to
import fertilisers at exorbitantly high prices, sell them to
farmers at high prices and perpetuate this whole cycle of
inflation and high prices of our basic needs. The Chief of
Army Staff has now to back up his words with actions and
results; we daresay, he will find it hard, if not impossible,
to do so because economics always speaks louder and last.
Analysis
Conservation of Bengali
Heritage
The conservation of heritage sites and its
public awareness should keep pace together. They are twin and
complementary in importance.
Mohammad Shahidul Islam
Bangladesh
is lucky enough to have inherited a colorful cultural legacy.
It is a country rich in archaeological wealth, especially of
the medieval period both during the Muslim and pre-Muslim
rules. Its heritage reveals the ancient legacies of the
Buddhist, Hindus and Muslims. The early history of Bangladesh
reveals that Buddhism received royal patronage from some
important ruling Hindu dynasties like the great Pal rulers,
the Chandras and the Deva Kings.
Under their patronage numerous well-organized monasteries
sprang up all over the country. The combination of Dravidian,
Indo-Aryan, Mongol /Mughal, Arab, Persian, Turkish, and West
European cultures have also enriched our heritage. Here,
kings, sultans and conquerors competed with each other to
build beautiful palaces, mosques and temples.
But we have failed to preserve many of these ancient
structures because of our collective carelessness. It is high
time to start heritage tourism with proper conservation of our
heritage sites. We cannot negate here the exigency of business
in this plan but the glorified past of Bangladesh would come
out to the world and shall bring name and fame for us.
Tourism is yet become established in Bangladesh as is the case
with heritage tourism. We are talking of its prospects in
presenting the image of Bangladesh to the world and fashioning
public awareness. People should know the rich background of
Bangladeshi culture and heritage. The concept of heritage
tourism is old. The phrase heritage tourism implies that the
visitor was actively seeking out verification of the country's
cultural and historical past. Generally heritage tourism means
traveling to experience the places and activities that
genuinely stand for the chronicles and people of the past and
present. These authentic experiences include extremely rare
historic resources.
There is also some argument over the meaning and scope of the
word heritage itself. According to the Ninth Edition of the
Concise Oxford Dictionary: "A nation's historical buildings,
monuments, countryside, etc., esp. when regarded as worthy of
preservation". And according to Chambers 21st Century
Dictionary: "A nation's mark of history, such as stately
buildings, countryside, cultural traditions, etc seen as the
nation's wealth to be inherited by future generations". That
additional phrase "cultural traditions" brings the definition
much closer to the one that most people engaged in
heritage-based tourism would employ. Accordingly, what stands
out is that without heritage a country cannot be finely
illustrated or tested in the world map.
Our heritage, shaped by nature and history, is a legacy passed
from one generation to the next. Our heritage helps us
understand and tell stories about this land and its people.
Still we have enough time to protect heritage places for at
least:
l reviving our past identity
l conferring them on future generations
l upholding social, spiritual, ethical and legal obligation
Heritage places are often described as either natural or
cultural heritage. In reality they often have a blend of
natural, historic and aboriginal heritage significance. For
example, the vast landscape of Paharpur, the largest monastery
south of Himalayas contains important terracotta plaques,
images of different gods and goddesses, potteries, coins,
inscriptions, ornamental bricks, minor clay objects,
ecosystems, wonderful native paintings and engravings, sites
of great spiritual significance and interesting historic
features. Understanding this multifaceted heritage place means
distinguishing all the different elements of significance.
All should work for the awareness of heritage from different
standpoints. The role of Ministry of Cultural Affairs for
preservation and awareness of historical and archeological
monuments and sites would come first, and then the close
coordination among various ministries, departments and
agencies should be highly active from the core of national
importance and Bangladesh image. Bangladesh Parjatan
Corporation [BPC]-National Tourism Organization [NTO] has also
virtual responsibilities to generate public awareness of
heritage. Already BPC does many activities through its
pamphlet, posters, films and website and its National Hotel
and Tourism Training Institute [NHTTI] puts Bangladeshi
Culture and Heritage as a compulsory subject in its all
courses. But the scene is very dark in the context of
Bangladesh education. Bangladeshi students are awfully unaware
of their rich Culture and Heritage: what does it mean? Why is
it important? Why should we conserve it? etc. They know only
"Bangladesh is a land of birds /rivers" but they do not know
really "Bangladesh is also a land of tourism".
Bhutan can be the right example of Bangladesh in the regard of
reviving culture and heritage. They let their children know
culture and heritage from primary level. Consequently they
learn to apprehend heritage with ethics and morality. They
love it religiously. The following steps can be thought for
Heritage awareness:
l From primary to higher-secondary level beside Bengali and
English, Heritage ought to be taught.
l Newspapers, television, radio and other media need to
produce shows and weekly supplementary on culture and
heritage.
l There would be traveling exhibitions to highlight unknown
aspects of heritage.
l Every year heritage festival in every district should be
observed.
l The government may designate religious experts from Muslim,
Christian, Hindu and Buddhism in the national awareness
committee to nourish and trace the fervor of religion in
heritage.
l Writers and experts on heritage have to be patronized to
raise awareness.
The conservation of heritage sites and its public awareness
should keep pace together. They are twin and complementary in
importance. A national committee for cultural relic's
protection should be set up soon to promote healthy
development of cultural relics. We have to be careful that in
the name of conservation, we can never change the message of
heritage. Improper or excessive development of heritage sites
may threaten the country's cultural relics. The government is
expected to formulate a series of rules and standards to
manage and protect cultural relics and create national
standards for both conservation and awareness.
(The writer is a Faculty of National Hotel and Tourism
Training Institute, Email: mohd-s-islam@myway.com)
Davos and the Response of Bangladesh
Our Chief Adviser drew the
attention of the participants at Davos highlighting the two
major concerns Bangladesh constantly fights with namely the
effects of climate change and lack of duty-free access to the
EU and American markets.
Md. Masum Billah
Davos
closed the annual meeting of the World's Economic Forum with
some hopes, aspirations, promises and warnings. This year's
event has drawn nearly 30 heads of state or governments, more
than 110 cabinet ministers and several hundred corporate
titans. More than 75 of the world's leading corporations
easily eclipsed the 25 heads of states and governments
present. US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, British Prime
Minster Gordon Brown, Ex-prime minister Tony Blair, US Ex
-secretary of state Henry Kissinger, Ban Ki Moon. Rock star
activist Bono, billionaire philanthropist Bill Gates and UN
Chief steered the conversation away from the global economy
and geopolitics towards issues such as malaria eradication,
poverty alleviation and climate change. Changing climate
stands as a major concern across the globe jeopardizing the
world economy.
Our Chief Adviser drew the attention of the participants at
Davos highlighting the two major concerns Bangladesh
constantly fights with namely the effects of climate change
and lack of duty-free access to the EU and American markets.
Tony Blair, cochairman of the forum, voiced strong support to
Bangladesh in these two aspects as Bangladesh has to pay a
heavy loss almost every year due to nature's wrath. The very
recent devastating cyclone brought untold miseries to the
people of coastal region and putting a huge undue pressure to
the government. The rising RMG sector has started experiencing
serious blow due to labor unrest. It also faces threat and
challenge as it has to vie with other ready made garments
exporting countries. It further faces problems due to the lack
of duty-free access to European Union countries and the
markets of USA. Our CA has rightly pointed out the problems
which gave food for thought to the participants who this year
put emphasis on poverty alleviation and hunger extending
opportunities to resource starved countries like Bangladesh.
Asian Development Bank president H Kuroda said to Dr.
Fakruddin Ahmed, "I'm greatly impressed with your government's
performance, particularly the reforms brought about in
governance and economic sectors". And he assured the Bank's
continued support for infrastructure and power and energy
sector development in Bangladesh. Dr. Fakruddin urged foreign
entrepreneurs to work as investment ambassadors of Bangladesh;
representatives of foreign companies who have already made
investment in the country called for implementing reform in
the financial sector to attract more overseas investment.
Foreign Corporation want to see the actual implementation of
reforms so far undertaken by the government in financial
sector. This fact was disclosed by Bangladesh's Permanent
representative to UN Office in Geneva Ambassador Dr. Debaprya
Bhattacharya who accompanied the Chief Adviser to Davos.
Fakruddin and the CEO of seven leading companies made
interactions during a dinner at a hotel in the snow covered
hilly resort town of Davos. He apprised them of the political
and economic background before the incumbent caretaker
government took over as well as administrative and economic
reforms undertaken by his government in the past one year.
The business representatives appreciated the government's
reformer agenda particularly the steps taken against
corruption and said power generation is one of the fundamental
elements to attract foreign investments and wanted to know if
coal and gas in Bangladesh are adequately being exploited.
Here lies our weakness. Still we have failed to ensure the
proper exploitation of our natural resource like coal and gas.
Definitely Bangladesh could have established itself as a
flourishing industrialized country if her natural resource had
been used properly. It can be attributed to political unrest
and the non-commitment of the politicians. However, Dr.
Fakruddin assured them that caretaker government is trying
hard to create an enabling atmosphere for foreign investment,
that Bangladesh has lot of potential for investment.
CEOs observed Bangladesh's image is better than many other
countries of the world but they apprehend vulnerability of the
country's economy. They wondered whether credible political
leadership would be in place through reforms after the
elections. They suggested time-bound decision on investment
and equal treatment for foreign companies like national
companies. The government must give a serious thought to this
issue. If the foreign investors don't get confidence, surely
the flow of foreign investment will be reduced.
The Davos event has long prided itself on showing the caring
side of capitalism although participants have criticized for
trumpeting big ideas on big issues in public while actually
expanding most of their energy on corridor schmoozing and
backroom deals. From the same Davos podium, the world's
richest man Bill Gates announced a grant of $19.9 million over
three years to initially help place improved rice varieties
and related technology into the hands of 400,000 small farmers
in South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. Rice is staple food for
2.4 billion people and provides more than 20% of their daily
calories intake and up to 70% for the poorest of the poor.
Gates said, "If we are serous about ending extreme hunger and
poverty around the world, we must be serious about
transforming agriculture for small farmers most of whom are
women." The cash injection is to fund projects to improve soil
quality, milk production, irrigation and seed development in a
host of poor African and Asian countries. The Bill and Melinda
Gates Foundation would enable the International Rice Research
Institute to acquire new funding to harness some of the
biggest unresolved problems in agriculture. The grant to Irri
is part of a package totaling $306 million that nearly doubles
Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation's investment s in
agriculture development initiatives in 2006
The session on 'Dividing the World Again' moderated by
Dominique Rossi, stood out as really interesting. Ambassador
Wu Jianmin, President of China's Foreign Affairs University
maintained that the agenda revealed the western psyche of
following a policy of 'divide and rule' to dominate the world.
Asian values believe in uniting the world by strengthening
commonweal and working out compromise on contentious issues.
Corporate responsibility rather than profit took centre stage
in Davos on January 25 as the annual get-together of business
chiefs turned its attention to issues of health, aid and
development the coordination of politics should not be
entirely confined to the world's advanced countries but also
be inclusive of developing country's stand point. This was
another important message of the meet despite the dividing
rule policy surfaced in the meet. United Nations Chief Ban Ki
Moon challenged the delegates to renew a commitment to the UN
Millennium Goals aimed at halving the extreme poverty,
boosting health and education and further improving women
across the developing world by 2015." Bill Gates said, "The
challenge here is to design a system project and recognition
to do more for the poor". He finally called for a new form of
'creative capitalism'. And this new form of 'creative
capitalism' can be achieved through the concerted efforts of
both resourceful and resource starved countries of the globe.
(The writer works as a specialist in Brac Education
Programme, PACE and regularly writes on various national and
international issues. He can be reached at mmbillah@dhaka.net
Phone: 9355253, 01715-401267)
Opinion
Cost
of Interdependence
It
is not yet clear what caused the damage Wednesday to two
submarine fiber optic cables off Egypt's Mediterranean coast
but the impact appears to have been considerable. Web access
throughout the Middle East and India has been widely disrupted
and international telephone calls were also affected as phone
companies worked to find spare capacity on other networks.
First estimates are that it may take at least a week to find
and repair the damaged cables. The impact of millions of
businesses and home users of the Internet and phone system is
likely to be considerable, both in inconvenience and economic
cost. One conspicuous casualty has been India's call-center
industry, which having lost around half of its bandwidth is
struggling to service clients in the UK and United States.
In the past three days, the corporate world has grappled with
the commercial implications of this disruption while domestic
users have been fuming at their inability to quickly update
their Facebook profiles or download pirated movies and
software. From a policy perspective, it must be hoped that
governments and communications experts are taking note of the
lessons that need to be learned from this event. The most
obvious is that the physical undersea cable networks that
carry massive flows of data every minute have to be designed
and built with additional lines. As it is, much of the world
is interconnected with numerous alternate routes, especially
across the Atlantic between Europe and the United States and
East Asia. But, as Wednesday's cut of two key cables showed,
other parts of the world are less connected to the World Wide
Web. How connected a region is to the Internet can clearly be
used as a benchmark of the region's development. For example,
setting aside the North African Region - which borders and
benefits from a key information superhighway in the
Mediterranean Sea - much of Africa is barely plugged into this
large and wholly invisible undersea network, and the backup
routes are few and far between.
The speed and power of the modern Internet, with hundreds of
thousands of servers and routers in a complex but
breathtakingly efficient network, have effectively abolished
distance. What you read in your newspaper every morning is
also available to billions of other people around the world.
Nevertheless, although it is often said that information flies
into computers out of the "ether", the reality is the Internet
still relies on physical connections. Even wireless
connections at some point in the system must connect to wires.
The technological fixes - the creation of more backup trunk
cables - will be expensive. But the players in this market,
such as FLAG Telecom, which is currently investing in a
$1.5-billion upgrade, called the Next Generation Network, will
also reap great rewards from boosting reliability and
capacity.
But in light of this week's Internet disruption, perhaps it's
worth noting that the business world managed to function
before the Internet and is pretty good at adapting to change.
Source: www.arabnews.com
Viewpoints
China's Yin, India's
Yang
Yet even when they compete for resources abroad, experts say
China and India have much to gain through cooperation.
Lee Hudson Teslik
Much
has been made of the rivalry between China and India, Asia's
emerging economic powers. For the most part, analysts frame
discussion of the two countries in competitive terms-we did
just this at CFR.org in June 2007, when Manjeet N. Kripalani
and Adam Segal debated whether India is likely to eclipse
China. There is no denying the competition between Beijing and
New Delhi, particularly when national pride comes into play.
But on a practical level, recent economic relations stand out
more for cooperation than
competitiveness. This new cordiality was on display January
14, when India's economist-turned-Prime Minister Manmohan
Singh and Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao announced plans to work
toward a $60 billion trade pact by 2010 (Times of India).
News of the possible trade deal stands out as the latest in a
series of developments tightening bonds between Beijing and
New Delhi. In 2006, China's President Hu Jintao became the
first Chinese leader in a decade to visit India. The countries
recently began holding regular joint military exercises (AFP),
and China supports India's bid (Hindu) to become a permanent
member of the UN Security Council. These political advances
come amid marked economic gains. Bilateral trade between India
and China has skyrocketed, increasing over tenfold since 2002
(NDTV). Total bilateral trade between the countries, which
amounts to roughly $34 billion, remains slightly smaller than
total trade between India and the United States (a little over
$38 billion), and substantially smaller than total U.S.-China
trade (over $354 billion). But the trade targets agreed to by
Singh and Wen seem likely to substantially broaden China-India
bilateral relations-even if the countries don't meet their $60
billion target.
China and India both hope to become major global trade powers.
In this way, they more directly compete with one another, as
outlined in a recent World Bank report about efforts in
Beijing and New Delhi to win contracts in Latin America and
the Caribbean. Yet even when they compete for resources
abroad, experts say China and India have much to gain through
cooperation. Writing in the December 2007 Harvard Business
Review, one expert points out that the very different paths
the countries have taken toward economic liberalization-with
intensive government oversight in China's case, versus a more
bottom-up approach in India's-have left India and China with
complementary economies. The article argues that businesses
gain from cross-border cooperation when they leverage China's
superior manufacturing plants and cheap labor, and then make
good on India's advantages in product design and development,
sales, and services.
Despite the gains to be had, several obstacles stand in the
way of more fluid economic relations between the countries. A
recent article in the Washington Quarterly, while lauding
improved China-India relations, notes several lingering
challenges (PDF). First and most basically, the countries
still dispute the contours of their Himalayan border, a relic
of a 1962 war (GlobalSecurity.org). In 2005, Singh and Wen
signed an agreement aimed at resolving the dispute (China
Daily), but the specifics have yet to be hammered out, and
regionally the issue remains prickly. More generally, the
Washington Quarterly article adds that each government remains
suspicious of the other's intentions, particularly when it
comes to regional power dynamics. Still, the economic stakes
are high enough that businesses find a way to blast through
cultural suspicions. As the Harvard Business Review article
puts it: "They have too much to lose by not working together."
(Lee Hudson Teslik is an Assistant Editor of Council on
Foreign Relations. Source: www.cfr.org)
Global Warming Objections
In short,
the sunspot theory is not a credible or plausible explanation
for global warming.
Chuck
Hall
Research
from climate scientists all over the world increasingly
demonstrates that human activities are playing a part in global
warming. Still, there are those who object to the idea that
human activities are responsible. These critics of climate
change science must answer the question: "If carbon dioxide
isn't responsible for the increase in global average
temperature, what is?"
Those who wish to deny the prevailing scientific opinion have
attempted to come up with alternative solutions to the question
of climate change. Two alternate explanations for global warming
seem to be gaining popularity.
The first explanation is that water vapor is a greenhouse gas,
and that increases in water vapor across the globe are
responsible for global warming. No proponent of this particular
theory has yet been able to explain where the sudden increase in
water vapor came from, nor why it began in the first place. The
second explanation is that sunspots are causing it. In other
words, 'hot spots' on the surface of the sun produce more heat,
and as this heat travels to Earth, it causes increases in global
temperature.
Note also that neither of these theories explains why the
increase in carbon dioxide emissions in our atmosphere is
positively correlated with the increase in global temperature.
In other words, both the sunspot theory and the water vapor
theory ignore carbon dioxide altogether, even though it is a
demonstrable fact that carbon dioxide in our atmosphere has been
steadily increasing.
On the sunspot theory, solar astronomer Peter Foukal says,
"There has been an intuitive perception that the sun's variable
degree of brightness, the coming and going of sunspots for
instance, might have an impact on climate."Foukal says that most
climate models (including ones used by the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change) already incorporate the effects of the
sun's waxing and waning power on Earth's weather.
According to a study by Foukal (Nature Magazine, September
2006), the difference in temperature caused by sunspot activity
is simply far too small to contribute significantly to global
warming. Foukal and his team of researchers gathered sunspot
activity data from as far back as 1874 and attempted to
correlate these records with temperature records gleaned from
ice core samples. They found that the data simply did not match
up.
The bottom line is that there is an only 0.1% temperature
variance in sunspot activity. According to Foukal, this variance
is far too small to have any major impact on the overall global
average temperature of the Earth. It also doesn't explain the
correlation between increased carbon dioxide in our atmosphere
and increased global average temperature. In short, the sunspot
theory is not a credible or plausible explanation for global
warming.
(Chuck Hall's latest book, Green Circles: A Sustainable
Journey from the Cradle to the Grave is now available at the
Culture Artist Web site at www.cultureartist.org. You may
contact Chuck by email at: chuck@cultureartist.org.)
Kidneys for sale
The donor's consent is typically secured through coercion or
under exploitative, unequal conditions.
Praful Bidwai
THE
ghoulish kidney transplantation racket unearthed near Delhi,
with ramifications across nations, has shocked the global
public. Amit Kumar alias Santosh Raut's operation involved
three hospitals, five diagnostic centres and 10 laboratories,
and more than 50 accomplices, including doctors and nurses,
"spotters" and touts who would lure potential donors with the
promise of jobs, and thugs who would force them to part with
their kidneys.
The 600-odd recipients included nationals of half-a-dozen
countries.
The racket couldn't have been conducted for years without
collusion on part of the police. Raut was a known offender
with a history of repeated arrests since 1993. Raut escaped
because he was tipped off. Two Greeks involved in his set-up
were also let off.
What demarcates Raut's racket from the kidney trade which
flourishes in many South Asian cities is muscle power.
Typically, extreme economic distress compels poor people to
sell their body parts. But Raut's goons would abduct their
victims and beat them into agreeing to kidney excision.
This further highlights police failure in enforcing India's
Transplantation of Human Organs Act (THOA) 1994, which
illegalises the sale of human organs and allows transplants
from brain-dead people. It allows organ donations by close
relatives without government clearance. All other relatives
must be cleared by an Authorisation Committee.
THOA however has a big loophole: no Committee approval is
needed if the donor feels "affection" or "attachment towards
the recipient". This is licence for abuse.
The Raut racket follows a familiar pattern. Rich people
suffering from end-stage renal disease are contacted by an
international organ trade network run by unscrupulous doctors
who prey upon the very poor. The victims are misled into
believing they'll get jobs and induced into selling a kidney
for as little as Rs 40,000 to Rs 1 lakh. The global kidney
bazaar is highly evolved, with a hierarchy of preferences and
prices. Kidneys from India or Pakistan sell for $1,000 to
$2,000; a Romanian kidney for $3,000-plus. A kidney from
Turkey costs $10,000. Mexico, Brazil and South Africa fall in
between.
The donor's consent is typically secured through coercion or
under exploitative, unequal conditions. It's not remotely free
or informed. Donors are quickly discharged without being
warned of risks. There's no follow-up treatment or monitoring
for possible kidney malfunction. Many end up ill and
destitute. Many poor countries have no laws to regulate organ
trading. In India, the law came years after transplantation
had already become established. In Pakistan, the law came only
last year.
Common everywhere is failure of enforcement. The reason, apart
from bribes, is the belief that the victims got a modicum of
"justice" because they were "compensated" with money; they
can, after all, survive with one kidney.
The only "injustice", many law-enforcers believe, is that of
disproportion: racketeering doctors, middlemen and brokers
make much larger sums, Rs 15-20 lakhs, than donors. This
belief, shared by a section of the subcontinental elite -
which also justifies child labour - betrays utter contempt for
the principle of inviolability of the human body, which is
foundational to any civilised society. It justifies the
robbery of vital organs. Organs like kidneys don't regenerate.
Donating them is different from donating blood.
This belief places an abysmally low value on the bodies of the
poor. This should be repugnant to anyone with elementary faith
in human solidarity or an essential compact among people,
regardless of their social rank. The idea that you can
cannibalise the bodies of the underprivileged is totally
unacceptable.
The injustice of disproportion is secondary. Even if all
middlemen were eliminated, it would still be unconscionable
for medical science to be used to transfer organs from the
poor to the rich. Ethically, treating human organs like
commodities remains extremely troubling, especially when
there's huge disproportion of power. Advocates of
"market-based solutions" to the kidney failure problem violate
this criterion.
In India, there's a big gap between those affected by
end-stage renal disease, about 1.5 lakh, and the number of
kidneys transplanted (under 4,000). Another 6,000 get
dialysis. But that gap can't be filled by sacrificing the
poor. Rather, we need more and cheaper dialysis facilities,
cadaver-based transplants (from the brain dead), and donations
by patients' relatives.
Unfortunately, subcontinental governments are coming under
pressure to "ease" transplant norms through "incentives" and
"organ-swapping". This is open to abuse.
Meanwhile, the problem of preventing Raut-style rackets cannot
be ducked. The inhuman practice of violating the bodies of
ultra-vulnerable people must be put down and severely
punished. This must provoke serious critical reflection on the
neoliberal economic policies we are pursuing, under which
growth aggravates destitution. It must also trigger police
reform.
Equally important, we need to re-educate doctors on medical
ethics and social responsibility. Our medical profession has
been complicit in all kinds of malpractices. The phenomenon of
India's "27 million missing women" caused by female foeticide
wouldn't have occurred without its active involvement in sex
determination and abortion.
It's a shame that the state too is indulgent towards the
perpetrators of this ghastly and shameful gender violence. So
a laughable 66 cases have been registered against doctors for
sex selection in all these years.
Yet, there's a smart way of zeroing in on clandestine organ
transplants. Their recipients are given immuno-suppressant
drugs to prevent rejection, such as cyclosporin, tacrolimus
and mycophenolate. These are only made by a handful of
companies like Novartis and Roche, which know exactly which
hospitals/clinics order them. They must be made to part with
the information.
But will our governments muster the will to do this?
Source:www.khaleejtimes.com
International
Al-Qaeda claims
attack on Israel’s embassy in Mauritania: Al Jazeera
AFP, Dubai
The Al-Qaeda terror group has claimed
an attack on the Israeli embassy in the Mauritanian
capital Nouakchott, Al Jazeera television reported Sunday.
"Al-Qaeda claims the attack against the Israeli embassy
buildings in Nouakchott," the Qatar-based satellite
channel announced on its screen without giving further
details.
Three unidentified gunmen opened fire on the embassy
Friday shortly after 2:00 am (0200 GMT), before fleeing as
Mauritanian embassy guards immediately returned fire. No
embassy staff were hurt but three French citizens were hit
by stray bullets outside a nightclub a few metres (yards)
from the embassy.
Together with Egypt and Jordan, Mauritania is only one of
three Arab League nations with which Israel has full
diplomatic relations.
Political pressure has however been increasing within the
Islamic republic straddling the Maghreb and black
sub-Saharan Africa, to sever the ties it established with
the Jewish state in 1999.
Malaysian PM says Indians will vote against ruling party
AFP,Kuala Lumpur
Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said the number of
votes from Indians for the ruling party will likely drop
in the coming polls, a report said Sunday, amid increasing
ethnic strife in Malaysia.
Ethnic Indians protested against alleged discrimination in
Muslim-majority Malaysia in a mass rally in November that
led to the indefinite detention of five leaders of the
Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf).
When asked if the issues raised by Hindraf, which has made
national headlines, would influence how Indians would vote
in upcoming polls, Abdullah told the Sunday Star
newspaper: "Yes, I think votes will be affected somewhat."
Analysts say general elections could be held in March.
Ethnic Indians, who complain of a lack of job and
educational opportunities, have been strong supporters of
Abdullah's National Front coalition since the country
gained independence from Britain in 1957.
Abdullah, who is also the finance minister, said he would
address Indian grievances, which include the destruction
of Hindu temples. "I have given instruction that whatever
grouses they have should be attended to," he said.
Sri Lanka marks freedom anniversary amid bombs and
fighting
AFP, Colombo
Sri Lanka marks its 60th independence day Monday amid bomb
attacks against civilians, ferocious fighting with Tamil
rebels and growing international concern over the island's
human rights record.
Freedom Day events in heavily-guarded Colombo will be held
despite mourning for 20 passengers killed by a bus bomb
Saturday in north-central Sri Lanka and six people injured
Sunday in a hand grenade attack at Sri Lanka's main zoo
near the capital, authorities said.
"Cultural and sporting events will also be held in
addition to the main event in Colombo," Karu Jayasuriya,
the chief organiser of the celebrations, told AFP.
President Mahinda Rajapakse blamed separatist Tamil Tiger
rebels for the bus attack and called for calm as security
forces kept up an offensive against Tamil guerrillas in
the north.
Rajapakse's government is preparing to put its military
might on display at a seafront promenade in Colombo
including tanks and multi-barrel rocket launchers-the most
effective weapon against the Tigers-and aircraft.
Monday's celebrations are the first major national event
since Colombo formally ended the Norwegian-arranged 2002
truce and vowed to crush the Liberation Tigers of Tamil
Eelam (LTTE) militarily.
Fighting between troops and the LTTE around the rebel-held
Wanni region in the north and the rest of the island left
nearly 1,000 people killed last month alone, according to
defence ministry figures.
Police spokesman N.K. Illangakoon defended holding the
celebrations despite fears of more rebel attacks in
Colombo, a city of 650,000 people.
"We can't allow terrorists to disrupt our Independence Day
celebrations," Illangakoon said. "We are providing maximum
security."
The military will deploy 4,100 troops for a ceremonial
parade in addition to drawing thousands of commandos and
paramilitary police forces from the provinces to beef up
security, he said.
Sri Lanka's government believes it has the upper hand
against the Tamil rebels and has ruled out any
negotiations until winning a militarily victory by
re-capturing northern territories controlled by the LTTE.
"We will hit if we are hit," Rajapakse told reporters at
his last press conference two weeks ago. "Terrorism must
be defeated. There are no good terrorists and bad
terrorists."
Sri Lanka had made similar vows to defeat the LTTE in the
course of the three decade long conflict, but widening
unrest has led key donors to Sri Lanka to cut or review
aid.
Sri Lanka's former colonial ruler Britain suspended its
marginal debt relief to Colombo last year citing human
rights concerns and a ballooning defence budget while the
US also stopped about 110 million dollars in aid.
However, the biggest scare came from Japan, the island's
largest single donor, which warned of an aid review if the
violence escalated further in the Indian Ocean island
republic.
Taliban, Al-Qaeda in the shadows in eastern Afghanistan
AFP, Sharan, Afghanistan
Using tactics
from executions to threatening late-night visits, the
Taliban and their Al-Qaeda allies may work largely in
hiding but there is no doubting their distinctive message.
They exert "strong pressure" on locals to cooperate with
them rather than with Afghan authorities and their
international partners, says Nawab Waziri, head of the
provincial council of Paktika on the border with Pakistan.
Most crudely, "they chop off heads or hands," Waziri told
AFP. Scores have been killed by the insurgents like that,
sometimes on allegations of "spying" for the government or
foreign military forces.
But they also operate more clandestinely. "They come
secretly to people in the middle of the night, masked, to
tell them what to do," he said.
"There are men who are Taliban in secret in the
villages... They cover their faces and talk to people in
other villages."
Sometimes there are "night letters"-written threats thrown
into schools or near homes under the cover of darkness.
Relatives of these secret operators never talk about them;
even if one is killed, they keep quiet, said Waziri. "The
Taliban who die are not identified by their families."
Waziri, in his 40s, joined some 700 other influential men
from Paktika at a shura, or traditional council, in the
provincial capital Sharan last week to debate the
insurgent threat.
"I ask you all to not support Al-Qaeda and to help the
government," national communications minister Amirzai
Sangin told the impressive gathering of tribal chiefs,
clerics and others.
Paktika and another border province, Khost, are "gateways"
into Afghanistan for "Al-Qaeda and of terrorism because
their camps are just on the other side of the border,"
said the official, who had come from Kabul.
After being driven from government in late 2001 by a
US-led international coalition, some Taliban and Al-Qaeda
took refuge in Pakistan's tribal zones.
There they regrouped in extremist sanctuaries and training
camps from which US and Afghan officials say they launch
attacks into Afghanistan.
A leading Al-Qaeda commander who led the terror network in
Afghanistan was believed to have been killed just across
from Paktika last week when a missile fired by a US drone
hit his hideout in Pakistan's North Waziristan area.
Iraqi PM warns of imminent battle against Qaeda
AFP, Baghdad
|